Skip to main content

Managers' Insurance or Pension Fund: The Differences in Numbers, and When Not to Switch

By Yesh Cash Editor· Editorial Team
13 min readUpdated November 2026

Managers' insurance (bituach menahalim) is a personal policy with an insurance company, while a pension fund is a pooled fund in which members guarantee one another. In practice managers' insurance is more expensive: in policies issued from 2004 the average is about 0.94% of the balance a year, against about 0.145% in comprehensive pension funds (Bituach-Net and Pension-Net data, September 2026). The real advantage of managers' insurance lies in old policies issued up to 2012 that carry a guaranteed conversion factor. You do not move a policy like that without doing the sums.

Disclosure: Educational information only, not pension advice. The numerical examples are illustrative. Your policy's terms are what count, and you check them in the policy and the annual statement.

The main differences

ItemComprehensive pension fundManagers' insurance
StructurePooled fund, mutual guarantee and actuarial balancingPersonal contract with an insurer, which carries the risk
Fee cap (products from 2013)6% of deposits, 0.5% of balance4% of deposits, 1.05% of balance
Actual fees, September 20261.54% of deposits, 0.145% of balance1.77% of deposits, 0.94% of balance (policies from 2004)
Conversion factorSet at retirement according to life expectancy thenGuaranteed in policies up to 2012; not in policies from 2013
Life and disability coverBuilt in (survivors and disability), uniform price under the fund rulesBought separately and tailored; cover terms fixed in the contract
Changing terms for existing saversPossible, under the fund rulesThe cover premium will not rise for existing savers, according to Kol Zchut
Open to new joinersYesOnly after a full pension fund deposit (see below)

The averages are asset-weighted averages we calculated from the Capital Market Authority's Pension-Net and Bituach-Net data for the September 2026 reporting period (retrieved 10 November 2026). The deposit-fee average covers only the policies that report a deposit fee (about 93% of assets); policies that report none are not counted as zero. Policies from 2004 to 2012 are not subject to the 2013 cap, so their average can exceed 1.05%.

Managers' insurance fees: the range between companies

Actual average fees in policies issued from 2004, asset-weighted for each company, then the range across the 7 companies reporting to Bituach-Net, September 2026 data:

Actual feeLowest averageHighest averageMedian companyWhole market, weighted
Of balance a year0.72%1.18%0.78%0.94%
Of deposits0.64%3.48%1.85%1.77%

These policies hold about 355.9 billion ₪ across the market. The deposit-fee range is very wide, five times from cheapest to most expensive, so check this component in your own policy rather than assuming it is "the same everywhere". Even the cheapest company on the balance charges five times the comprehensive pension fund average.

Why the Commissioner's 2025 report shows 0.79%: the report describes 2025, and in Bituach-Net the asset-weighted average in December 2025 was 0.77% of the balance, almost the same figure. From January 2026 the two largest companies in the field report higher balance fees, one of them about 1.18% instead of about 0.70%, and that is what lifted the market average to 0.94%. When you compare a policy, check the fees in your own annual statement.

In older policies issued between 1992 and 2003 the reported fees are higher: about 2.2% of the balance on an asset-weighted average (1.9% to 2.8% by company), because in some of them the fee includes a variable component derived from profits. These policies charge no deposit fee.

In shekels: on a balance of 300,000 ₪, a fee of 0.94% of the balance costs about 2,820 ₪ a year, against about 435 ₪ at a pension fund's 0.145%: a gap of about 2,385 ₪ a year, before new deposits and before the return that money would have earned. That is why, in a policy without a guaranteed factor, fees are nearly the whole story. Work out the long-term gap with your own figures in the management fees calculator.

Who can still join managers' insurance

Since September 2023, new managers' insurance is open only to people who first deposit enough into a pension fund. According to Kol Zchut, as of 2026:

An employee may deposit into managers' insurance only if their salary exceeds twice the average wage, 27,538 ₪ a month, and at least 5,645.29 ₪ has already been deposited for them into a pension fund that month.

A self-employed person may do so only if they have already deposited at least 67,743.48 ₪ into a pension fund that year.

So for most workers managers' insurance is no longer an alternative to a pension fund but an extra layer on top of it. The question "which is better" today mainly concerns people who already hold a policy.

The guaranteed factor: how to put a number on the advantage

Up to 2012 insurers sold policies in which the pension is not affected by rising life expectancy. Since 2013 new policyholders do not get a guaranteed factor. Mind the name: this is a conversion factor (balance to pension), not a "commutation factor"; commutation is a lump-sum withdrawal at retirement.

An illustrative example only: a balance of 1,000,000 ₪ at retirement. In an old policy the guaranteed factor is, say, 190; in a pension fund the factor set at retirement is, say, 215.

ItemFactorMonthly pension
Policy with guaranteed factor190about 5,263 ₪
Pension fund215about 4,651 ₪
Differenceabout 612 ₪ a month, about 7,300 ₪ a year

Over 20 years of pension the difference reaches about 147,000 ₪, before indexation. That is the order of magnitude: hundreds of thousands of shekels for a saver with a large balance, not "millions" for a typical saver. To offset a gap like that, the policy's higher fees would have to cost more than this over the remaining years, and that is a calculation you do with the real factor in your own policy.

Where to find the factor: in the policy terms and the annual statement. In some policies the factor is guaranteed only for money deposited up to a certain date, and a different factor applies to later deposits. Ask the insurer for a breakdown of factors by deposit period.

The periods: policies from before 2008 may be "capital" policies, paying a lump sum at retirement on money deposited until then. Policies from 2008 to 2012 pay an annuity, with a guaranteed factor. Policies from 2013 pay an annuity, with no guaranteed factor and with a fee cap.

Managers' insurance returns: Bituach-Net data

General-track returns in policies issued from 2004, according to the Capital Market Authority's Bituach-Net, as of September 2026. The range across the five largest general tracks by assets, with the median in brackets:

MeasureRange across the five largest tracks
Actual balance fee0.86% to 1.11% (0.88%)
3-year annual average11.4% to 13.14% (12.7%)
5-year annual average7.16% to 8.12% (7.81%)

For comparison, the general track in the large pension funds returned a 5-year annual average of about 8.9% to 9.7% over the same period, with balance fees of about 0.15%. Part of the gap is explained by fees. Past returns do not predict future returns. Pension fund data: pension fund returns (Hebrew).

Loss of working capacity in managers' insurance

In managers' insurance, cover for loss of working capacity is bought separately. According to Kol Zchut, the employer must include in its share the purchase of cover guaranteeing 75% of the insured salary, even if this raises its share beyond 6.5%, provided that the savings contributions and the cover together do not exceed 7.5% of salary.

Two things to check in the policy:

The definition. Under an "occupational" definition the policy pays if you cannot work in your own profession; under a broader definition, only if you cannot do other reasonable work. The occupational definition protects more.

The waiting period and end age. How many months pass before the first payment, and up to what age the benefit is paid.

How insurers pay disability claims. In the Capital Market Authority's service index for 2025, for loss of working capacity, the overall scores of the six insurers ranged from 73 to 80 (average 76). On the claim-payment-rate component scores were 65 to 76 (average 71), far below term life insurance (average 93) and health insurance (80): relatively more claims are rejected in this field, which is why the policy definition matters so much. In 2025, 9,060 disability claims were handled to completion and about 888 million ₪ was paid to policyholders.

In a comprehensive pension fund the disability pension is built in, so anyone moving from managers' insurance to a fund gets cover under the fund's rules, which are not necessarily the same.

What happens on death

In managers' insurance the beneficiaries you named receive the policy balance, plus the life insurance (term) sum if such cover was bought in the policy. You set the sum and the beneficiaries in the policy and can check them in the annual statement.

In a comprehensive pension fund the survivors, spouse and children, receive a monthly pension under the fund's rules, not a lump sum. Anyone moving from managers' insurance to a fund swaps a lump sum for a pension, and should check that this suits the family.

Service in managers' insurance: a small gap overall, a big one on the phone

In the 2025 service index (published October 2026), for life insurance combined with savings, that is managers' insurance, the overall scores of the seven insurers ranged from 77 to 83, average 81. For comparison, the pension fund average was 79. The big gap between companies is phone response time: from 52 at the lowest to 94 at the highest. The Capital Market Authority publishes each company's score.

Should you move managers' insurance to a pension fund

A policy from 2013 onwards, with no guaranteed factor: the comparison is mainly fees and returns. If the policy's fees are well above the funds' average (0.145% of the balance and about 1.54% of deposits in September 2026), a move deserves serious thought. Check the new disability cover first.

A policy up to 2012 with a guaranteed factor: calculate before any step. A middle option is to leave the existing balance in the policy and direct only new deposits to a pension fund. That keeps the factor for the money already saved.

A capital policy from before 2008: the right to a lump sum on the old money is lost when moving to an annuity product.

According to Kol Zchut, you cannot go back to an old product after leaving it: managers' insurance with a guaranteed factor, a capital provident fund or a guaranteed-return policy. A move out of an old product is one-way.

Transferring managers' insurance

You submit a request at the body you are moving to: a pension fund, another insurer or a provident fund. The old body transfers the money within 20 business days. Moving from a pension fund to managers' insurance requires leaving a minimum amount in the fund according to the number of months you were insured in it, according to Kol Zchut. Moving between products is not a tax event.

Questions to check in the annual statement before deciding

1. What the deposit and balance fees are, and what the market average is.

2. Whether there is a guaranteed factor, what it is, and which deposits it applies to.

3. What the life and disability cover costs, and what the definition is.

4. What the 5-year return is in your track, against the same track in the funds.

Sources: Kol Zchut articles on managers' insurance, management fee caps, and transfers between pension providers and products; Capital Market Authority Bituach-Net and Pension-Net data (data.gov.il), reporting period September 2026, retrieved 8 November 2026; Capital Market Authority service index for 2025 (October 2026).

Educational information, not advice

This page explains rules and figures as of its update date. It does not assess your personal situation. Before deciding on an amount, a track or a product, check the figures with the official body, and for a complex case speak to a licensed professional.

Content is checked against official and authoritative sources: National Insurance, the Israel Tax Authority, the Bank of Israel, the Central Bureau of Statistics, the Capital Market Authority, the Israel Securities Authority, gov.il, Kol Zchut and the law texts (Updated November 2026). We are not affiliated with any of them. How we check

Frequently asked

Expand/collapse: What is the difference between managers' insurance and a pension fund?

A pension fund is a pooled fund with a mutual guarantee and built-in disability and survivors' cover. Managers' insurance is a personal contract with an insurer, with cover bought separately. Managers' insurance is more expensive: in policies from 2004, an average of 0.94% of the balance in September 2026 against 0.145% in comprehensive funds. Policies up to 2012 sometimes carry a guaranteed conversion factor.

Expand/collapse: Should I move my managers' insurance to a pension fund?

In a policy from 2013 with no guaranteed factor, the comparison is fees and returns, and a move is worth considering when fees are high. In a policy up to 2012 with a guaranteed factor, calculate first; you can leave the balance in place and direct only new deposits to a fund. Leaving an old product is irreversible.

Expand/collapse: What is a guaranteed conversion factor in managers' insurance?

A fixed factor in the policy that does not change when life expectancy rises, so the pension will not shrink because of it. Insurers sold such policies up to 2012, and since 2013 new policyholders do not get one. On a balance of a million shekels, a 25-point difference in the factor is worth about 600 ₪ a month.

Expand/collapse: What are the management fees in managers' insurance?

In policies from 2013 the cap is 4% of deposits and 1.05% of the balance a year. In practice, in policies issued from 2004, the asset-weighted average in September 2026 was 1.77% of deposits and 0.94% of the balance, according to Bituach-Net. In policies opened before 2013 this cap does not apply, and the fees are fixed in the contract.

Expand/collapse: What does loss of working capacity cover in managers' insurance include?

A monthly benefit if you lose the ability to work. The employer must buy cover guaranteeing 75% of the insured salary, within a ceiling of 7.5% of salary for savings and cover together. Check the definition, occupational or general, the waiting period and the age at which cover ends.

Expand/collapse: Can I still open a new managers' insurance policy?

Only under conditions. Since September 2023 an employee may deposit into managers' insurance only if their salary is above 27,538 ₪ a month and at least 5,645.29 ₪ has already been deposited for them into a pension fund that month, as of 2026. A self-employed person must first deposit at least 67,743.48 ₪ a year into a pension fund.

Expand/collapse: What do beneficiaries receive from managers' insurance on death?

The beneficiaries named in the policy receive the balance, plus the life insurance sum if such cover was bought in the policy, usually as a lump sum. In a comprehensive pension fund, by contrast, survivors receive a monthly pension under the fund's rules. Check the cover and beneficiaries in the policy and annual statement.

Expand/collapse: What returns does managers' insurance earn?

According to Bituach-Net for September 2026, in the large general tracks of policies from 2004 the 5-year annual average ranged from 7.16% to 8.12%, and the 3-year from 11.4% to 13.14%. The general track in the large pension funds averaged about 8.9% to 9.7% over 5 years. Part of the gap is explained by higher fees.

More topics